GST Litigation Management (2026): ₹10,000 Notice Threshold, Penalty as a Charge and Reduced Penalties

Last updated: 10 October 2026 · Written and reviewed by CA Meet Dhrangadhariya, CSM & Co LLP

Quick summary

  • No show cause notice under sections 73, 74 or 74A where the tax involved is below ₹10,000. Exactly ₹10,000 meets the threshold, so a notice may issue at that figure.
  • The ₹10,000 is tested on the aggregate of CGST, SGST or UTGST, IGST and cess. No single head has to reach ₹10,000 on its own, and credit wrongly availed or utilised counts towards it.
  • Interest, late fee and penalty are excluded from the test. Only tax, including the applicable cess, is counted.
  • Where tax, interest and the reduced penalty are paid voluntarily in time, the amount called a penalty is renamed a “charge”. The quantum does not change, it is payable on top of tax and interest, and it is deposited under the head “Others”.
  • A reduced penalty of 5% applies in non-fraud cases where tax and interest are paid within 30 days of the adjudication order under section 73, or 60 days under section 74A, and the ₹10,000 minimum penalty in non-fraud cases goes.

A large share of GST litigation is not about serious money. It is about small demands that cost more to contest than they are worth, and that nobody can afford to ignore because an unanswered notice becomes an order.

The 57th GST Council took aim at that directly. The FAQ on litigation management of 09/10/2026 fills in the mechanics of two changes, and the press release of 08/10/2026 carries the rest.

All of this is recommended, not enacted. The amendments to sections 73, 74 and 74A have to be passed and notified before any of it bites, and a notice you hold today is governed by the law as it stands.

The ₹10,000 floor on show cause notices

No show cause notice under sections 73, 74 or 74A is to be issued where the tax involved is less than ₹10,000. The FAQ answers the four questions that decide how that works in practice.

Question Answer
Tax is exactly ₹10,000 Threshold is met, so a notice may be issued. It is ₹10,000 or more
Demand spans CGST, SGST or UTGST, IGST and cess Tested on the aggregate. No single head needs to reach ₹10,000 by itself
Do interest, late fee and penalty count No. Only tax, including the applicable cess
Credit wrongly availed or utilised Counts, and amounts across heads are aggregated

Two of those cut in opposite directions, which is worth being clear-eyed about. Excluding interest and penalty from the computation is taxpayer-friendly, because a small tax demand carrying years of interest still falls below the line. Aggregating across heads is not, because four sub-₹10,000 amounts under different heads can combine into a notice that none of them would have supported alone.

Pending matters are covered too. The Council recommended a statutory provision so that notices and appeals involving less than ₹10,000 that are pending when the threshold comes into force are decided as if the threshold had been in force when the notice was issued. That is the part worth acting on, because it could dispose of live files rather than merely preventing future ones.

Penalty becomes a “charge” on voluntary payment

Where the full tax is paid voluntarily, along with interest and the prescribed reduced penalty, within the specified time, the amount presently called a penalty is to be called a charge. The FAQ is careful about what that does and does not mean.

  • It does not change the amount. The quantum payable stays exactly as prescribed.
  • It is payable in addition to tax and interest. To get the benefit of proceedings being concluded, you pay tax, applicable interest and the prescribed reduced amount, within the timeline.
  • It is deposited under the head “Others”, in accordance with the prescribed payment mechanism.

So this is a relabelling, not a discount. Its value is reputational rather than financial: an amount recorded as a charge rather than a penalty does not carry the same implication of culpability, which matters when a business has to disclose its tax position to a bank, an auditor, an acquirer or a tender authority. Worth knowing before anyone reads it as a saving.

Reduced penalties, and the minimum that goes

From the press release, alongside the FAQ items:

  • A reduced penalty of 5% in non-fraud cases, where the tax together with interest is discharged within 30 days of the adjudication order under section 73, or within 60 days under section 74A.
  • The condition of a minimum penalty of ₹10,000 in non-fraud cases is removed. Where a demand is small, the penalty is no longer floored at a figure that could exceed the tax itself.
  • The maximum general penalty under section 125 comes down from ₹25,000 to ₹10,000.

The 5% is the one to diarise. It turns the period immediately after an adjudication order into a decision point: pay now at 5%, or contest and lose the concession. That calculation needs doing quickly, and on the merits, not by default.

Appeals: a ceiling on pre-deposit

For an order that carries only a penalty and no demand of tax, the provisos to section 107(6) and section 112(8) are to be amended to cap the pre-deposit at ₹40 crore, being ₹20 crore under CGST and ₹20 crore under SGST or UTGST, for an appeal to the Appellate Authority and to the Appellate Tribunal respectively.

Separately, section 115 is to be made a standalone provision for the rate of interest on refund of pre-deposit, with a circular to clarify the position. Interest on money you had to park to exercise a right of appeal has been a recurring grievance, and a dedicated provision is the right fix.

Better notices, by instruction

The Council also recommended a circular giving tax officers comprehensive guidelines on the issue of demand notices and adjudication and appeal orders, covering:

  • the quality of notices and orders, and their timely issuance;
  • proper invocation of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts, only on the merits of each case; and
  • adherence to natural justice, including the conduct of personal hearings.

The second of those is the substantive one. Invoking the fraud limb extends the limitation period and raises the penalty, and where it is pleaded as a matter of routine rather than on the facts, the taxpayer carries the cost of rebutting it. An instruction is not a statutory bar, but it gives something concrete to cite in a reply.

One change that runs the other way

Not everything here favours the taxpayer, and it would be misleading to present the package as if it did. The Council also recommended introducing a validation clause in the CGST Act to validate notices that courts have held invalid on the ground that they were issued for multiple financial years.

In plain terms, a defect that several courts have treated as fatal to a notice is to be cured by statute. If you have a matter running on exactly that ground, it deserves attention now rather than after the amendment, and it is worth discussing with your advisers how a validation clause would interact with your case.

What to do now

  1. List every live notice and appeal where the tax involved is under ₹10,000. If the threshold is enacted with the pending-cases provision, those should fall away.
  2. Compute the threshold the way the FAQ does: aggregate across heads, tax and cess only, exclude interest, late fee and penalty, and include credit wrongly availed or utilised.
  3. Put the 5% window in your calendar the day an adjudication order arrives in a non-fraud case: 30 days under section 73, 60 days under section 74A.
  4. If you are relying on the multiple-financial-years ground, take advice before the validation clause arrives.
  5. Do not read “charge” as a reduction. Budget the same amount.
  6. Wait for the notifications. None of this is in force yet.

How CSM & Co LLP can help

We can review your pending notices and appeals against the proposed ₹10,000 threshold and identify the matters that should fall away, compute the threshold correctly where a demand spans several tax heads or arises from credit said to be wrongly availed, advise on whether to take the 5% reduced penalty or contest within the 30 or 60 day window, draft replies that meet an improperly invoked fraud allegation head on, and assess the effect of the proposed validation clause on a matter running on the multiple-financial-years ground. Please reach out to our team and we will be happy to assist.

Frequently asked questions

If the tax is exactly ₹10,000, can a notice still be issued?

Yes. The threshold is treated as met where the tax, including the applicable cess, is ₹10,000 or more, so a show cause notice may be issued at exactly ₹10,000.

Is the ₹10,000 tested head by head?

No. It is determined on the aggregate amount of tax under CGST, SGST or UTGST, IGST and cess. No individual head needs to reach ₹10,000 by itself.

Do interest and penalty count towards the ₹10,000?

No. Only the amount of tax, including the applicable cess, is counted. Interest, late fee and penalty are excluded from the test.

Does the threshold apply to wrongly availed input tax credit?

Yes. The tax relating to credit wrongly availed or utilised counts, and where it arises under more than one head those amounts are aggregated.

Does calling a penalty a “charge” reduce what I pay?

No. The substitution does not alter the quantum. The same amount is payable, on top of tax and interest, and it is deposited under the head “Others”.

What is the reduced penalty for paying early?

In non-fraud cases, 5% where the tax and interest are discharged within 30 days of the adjudication order under section 73, or within 60 days under section 74A. The minimum penalty of ₹10,000 in non-fraud cases is also being removed.

What happens to a pending notice below ₹10,000?

The Council recommended a statutory provision so that notices and appeals involving less than ₹10,000 and pending when the threshold comes into force are decided as if the threshold had been in force when the notice was issued.

Official sources

Related reading

Disclaimer

This article is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered professional advice. Please consult a qualified expert for advice tailored to your specific situation. The author and website owner are not liable for any errors or actions based on this content.

Related GST reading

Cost of Acquisition for Capital Gains: Gifted, Inherited and Pre-2001 Assets (Tax Year 2026-27)

Last updated: 16 August 2026 · Written and reviewed by CA Meet Dhrangadhariya, CSM & Co LLP

Quick summary

  • A gift, will or inheritance is not a transfer, so the giver pays no capital gains tax. The receiver takes over the previous owner’s cost of acquisition and counts his holding period (section 70, section 73 Table serial 1, section 2(101)).
  • For assets acquired before 1 April 2001, the cost is the actual cost or the fair market value on that date, at your option; for land or building the fair market value is capped at the stamp duty value (section 90(9) and (10)).
  • For listed equity shares and equity-oriented fund units bought before 1 February 2018, the cost is the higher of actual cost and the lower of the value on 31 January 2018 and the sale price (section 90(7)).
  • If the previous owner’s cost cannot be found, his cost is the fair market value on the date he acquired it (section 90(11)).

To compute a capital gain you subtract the cost of acquisition from the sale price. For an asset you bought, that is simple. For an asset you received as a gift or inheritance, or that has been in the family since before 2001, the Income-tax Act, 2025 has specific rules. They are in sections 73 and 90.

Gifts and inheritance: no tax on receipt of the asset

  • A transfer by gift, will or irrevocable trust by an individual or HUF is not a transfer for capital gains (section 70(1)(b)), and a partition of a HUF is also outside it (section 70(1)(a)). The giver does not pay capital gains tax.
  • The receiver is not taxed on a gift of money or property received from a relative, on the occasion of marriage, under a will or by way of inheritance, or in contemplation of death (section 92(3)). A gift from a non-relative above ₹50,000 in a year, in cash or property, is taxed as income from other sources (section 92(2)(m)). “Relative” includes the spouse, brothers and sisters, and lineal ascendants and descendants and their spouses (section 92(5)(g)).
  • Income from an asset you gift to your spouse or minor child is generally added to your own income (section 99, income of other persons included), and a house gifted to a spouse or minor child remains yours for house property tax (section 25).

The receiver’s cost and holding period

When the receiver sells the asset:

  • Cost of acquisition is the cost for which the previous owner acquired it, increased by the cost of improvement borne by the previous owner or by the receiver (section 73(1), Table serial 1).
  • Previous owner means the last owner who acquired the asset in a way other than gift, will, inheritance, trust transfer, distribution on liquidation and the other modes in that serial (section 73(2)(a)).
  • Holding period includes the period the previous owner held the asset (section 2(101)(c)(B)(I)).
  • If the cost to the previous owner cannot be found, it is taken as the fair market value on the date he acquired the asset (section 90(11)).
  • Cost of improvement covers capital expenditure on additions and alterations. For an asset that came to the previous owner before 1 April 2001, only expenditure on or after 1 April 2001 counts (section 90(1)(b)(i)). It excludes expenditure already claimed against house property, business or other sources income (section 90(2)).

Assets held since before 1 April 2001

For an asset that became yours, or the previous owner’s, before 1 April 2001, the cost of acquisition is the actual cost or the fair market value on 1 April 2001, at your option (section 90(9)(a) and (b)). For land or building the fair market value on 1 April 2001 cannot exceed the stamp duty value on that date, where it is available (section 90(10)).

Shares and units bought before 1 February 2018 (grandfathering)

For long-term equity shares of a company, units of an equity-oriented fund or units of a business trust that are covered by section 198 and were acquired before 1 February 2018, the cost of acquisition is the higher of:

  • (a) the actual cost; and
  • (b) the lower of (i) the fair market value, and (ii) the sale price.

The fair market value is the highest quoted price on 31 January 2018 for a listed asset, the highest price on the nearest earlier trading day if there was no trade that day, and the net asset value for an unlisted unit (section 90(8)). For shares not listed on 31 January 2018 but listed on the transfer date, the Act gives an indexed cost formula.

Other cost rules

Asset Cost of acquisition
Bonus shares or other financial assets allotted without payment on the basis of holding Nil (section 90(6)(d))
Rights shares you subscribe for The amount you paid (section 90(6)(c))
The right to subscribe, if you renounce it Nil (section 90(6)(b))
Shares you buy from the person who renounced the right The price paid to him plus the amount paid to the company (section 90(6)(e))
Shares after consolidation, sub-division or conversion Cost worked out from the original shares (section 90(9)(d))
Shares on distribution of assets in liquidation Fair market value on the date of distribution (section 90(9)(c))
Shares allotted under an ESOP or RSU The fair market value taxed as a perquisite (section 73, serial 4)
Goodwill, brand, tenancy rights and other rights The purchase price, or nil in other cases (section 90(3))

Examples

1. Inherited house. Your father bought a house in 1990 for ₹2,00,000. Its fair market value on 1 April 2001 was ₹10,00,000, below the stamp duty value on that date. You inherit it in 2018 and sell it in September 2026 for ₹80,00,000. You can choose the cost: ₹2,00,000 (actual) or ₹10,00,000 (value on 1 April 2001). Choose ₹10,00,000, which gives the lower gain. The holding period includes your father’s, so the gain is long-term: 80,00,000 - 10,00,000 = ₹70,00,000. Tax is at 12.5% without indexation, or, as the house was acquired before 23 July 2024, the lower of that and 20% with indexation, if you are a resident individual (section 197).

2. Gifted shares. Your father gives you listed shares he bought in 2015 for ₹1,00,000. They were worth ₹3,00,000 on 31 January 2018. You sell them in 2026 for ₹5,00,000. The cost is the higher of ₹1,00,000 and the lower of ₹3,00,000 and ₹5,00,000, that is ₹3,00,000. The gain is ₹2,00,000, long-term, and taxable above ₹1,25,000 at 12.5%.

3. Gift from a friend. If a friend (not a relative) gives you land with a stamp duty value of ₹20,00,000, you are taxed on ₹20,00,000 as income from other sources in the year you receive it (section 92(2)(m)). That value is then your cost of acquisition if you sell the land later (section 73, serial 17).

Points to keep in mind

  • Keep the documents of the previous owner’s cost and any improvements. For old assets, a registered valuer’s report for the value on 1 April 2001 supports the option.
  • The cost of acquisition cannot include interest you claimed as a deduction elsewhere (section 72(3)).
  • For ESOP shares and shares of a foreign company, see our posts on ESOP taxation and on capital gains.
  • If the property was inherited, check whether the heir needs a will or legal heir certificate to prove the mode of acquisition.

Frequently asked questions

Is there capital gains tax when I gift or inherit an asset?

No. A transfer by gift, will or inheritance is not a transfer for capital gains (section 70(1)(b)), and the receiver is not taxed on a gift from a relative or on an inheritance (section 92(3)). Tax arises when the receiver later sells the asset.

What is the cost of an inherited or gifted asset?

The cost for which the previous owner acquired it, plus any cost of improvement borne by the previous owner or by you (section 73(1), Table serial 1). “Previous owner” is the last owner who acquired it other than by gift, will, inheritance or one of the other modes in that serial.

Does the holding period of the giver count?

Yes. The period for which the previous owner held the asset is included in your holding period (section 2(101)(c)), so an asset held by the giver for a long time is long-term in your hands even if you sell soon after receiving it.

What if the asset was bought before 1 April 2001?

You may take either the actual cost or its fair market value on 1 April 2001. For land or building the fair market value cannot exceed the stamp duty value on that date (section 90(9) and (10)). The same applies where the previous owner held it before that date.

How are shares bought before 1 February 2018 treated?

For long-term listed equity shares, units of an equity-oriented fund or a business trust, the cost is the higher of the actual cost and the lower of (i) the highest quoted price on 31 January 2018 (or net asset value for unlisted units) and (ii) the sale price (section 90(7) and (8)).

What is the cost of bonus and rights shares?

Bonus shares: nil. Rights shares: the amount you paid for them. A right to subscribe that you renounce: nil (section 90(5) and (6)).

Official sources

Related reading

Disclaimer

This article is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered professional advice. Please consult a qualified expert for advice tailored to your specific situation. The author and website owner are not liable for any errors or actions based on this content.

WhatsApp