Professional Fees Paid to a Partner: Does the Section 35(e) Limit Apply?

Last updated: 23 October 2026 · Written and reviewed by CA Meet Dhrangadhariya, CSM & Co LLP

Quick summary

  • A firm can deduct a working partner’s remuneration only if the partnership deed authorises it and only within the aggregate limit in section 35(e) of the Income-tax Act, 2025; fees for separate professional services are not named in the section.
  • The Supreme Court has held that a commission paid to a partner stays under the old section 40(b) even if it is paid under a separate contract; the “different capacities” relief it accepts covers interest only.
  • We found no reported Supreme Court or High Court judgment on fees paid to a partner for an independent practice, so the view that they fall outside section 35(e) is arguable but untested.
  • The safer plan is to fit the fee under the limit together with normal remuneration, authorise it in the deed before the year starts, and keep proof of an independent practice and of market rates.

A partner in a firm often wears more than one hat. He may run his own consultancy, practise a profession or sell goods through his own business, and the firm may hire him for a specific job. When the firm pays him, the Income-tax Act, 2025 (from 01/04/2026) raises one question first: is this remuneration to a partner, which is deductible only within a limit, or an ordinary business expense paid to an outside supplier who happens to be a partner?

The answer matters in money. A working partner’s remuneration is deductible only if the partnership deed authorises it, and only up to the aggregate limit in section 35(e); anything above the limit is added back to the firm’s income. This post covers what the section says, what the Supreme Court has decided, how a fee for services differs from a purchase of goods, and how to structure the payment so that the firm is not left exposed. It builds on our post on partners’ remuneration and interest under section 35(e), which explains the limit in detail.

An example to keep in mind

Here is an illustrative case. A firm of software consultants has a working partner who also runs his own forensic analysis practice, registered under GST. The practice serves other companies at the same rates, and it also sells goods to the firm at market price. For one assignment the firm pays him ₹6,00,000 as fees. Can the firm deduct all of it, or does it count towards the limit on partners’ remuneration?

What section 35(e) covers

  • The section applies to expenditure of a firm “in the nature of salary, bonus, commission or remuneration, by whatever name called” paid to a partner (section 35(e)(i) and (ii)).
  • Remuneration to a partner who is not a working partner is not deductible at all (section 35(e)(i)).
  • Remuneration to a working partner is deductible only if the partnership deed applicable for the period authorises it, and only if the total for all working partners is within the limit: on the first ₹6,00,000 of book profit, ₹3,00,000 in case of a loss or 90% of the book profit, whichever is higher, and on the balance 60% (section 35(e)(ii) and (iii)).
  • A working partner is an individual actively engaged in conducting the affairs of the business or profession of the firm (section 35(e)(v)(B)).
  • Book profit is the net profit in the profit and loss account, computed under Chapter IV-D, increased by the remuneration to all partners if it has been deducted (section 35(e)(v)(A)).

The section does not use the words “professional fees”, and it does not mention purchases of goods. That gap is what this post is about.

The old section 40(b) spoke of “any payment of salary, bonus, commission or remuneration”. The 2025 Act speaks of expenditure “in the nature of” those items. Both versions add “by whatever name called”, so the label on the invoice does not decide the question. We have not found a decision on whether the new wording changes anything.

What the Supreme Court has said

Rashiklal & Co. v. CIT, (1998) 229 ITR 458 (SC), decided on 09/12/1997. A firm paid ₹28,579 as commission to one of its partners under a separate agreement of 1978, at 37 paise for every tonne of mineral the firm sold. The firm said he received it as the karta (head) of his Hindu undivided family (HUF) and not as a partner. The Supreme Court rejected that. It held that a firm is only a collective name for its partners, that a partner acts in his personal capacity within the firm, and that the old section 40(b) bars a deduction for commission paid to a partner even where a special contract provides for it.

Brij Mohan Das Laxman Das v. CIT, (1997) 223 ITR 825 (SC), decided on 10/12/1996, and Suwalal Anandilal Jain v. CIT, (1997) 224 ITR 753 (SC), decided on 10/03/1997. A partner who was karta of an HUF had also lent his own money to the firm. The Supreme Court held that the interest on that loan was not caught by section 40(b), accepting that one person can deal with a firm in more than one capacity. In Rashiklal the Court explained that those cases rested on an Explanation to the section that dealt only with interest, with no counterpart for commission. The 2025 Act keeps the same relief only for interest (section 35(e)(iv)(A) and (B)).

What these cases do not decide. All three involved a partner who represented an HUF. None of them concerns a partner who runs a genuine independent profession and bills the firm for a separate assignment, and in our search of reported decisions available online we found no judgment of the Supreme Court or of any High Court that decides that point either way. Rashiklal was also decided under the old section 40(b), which then barred such payments to any partner outright, while the present section allows a working partner’s remuneration within limits. Even so, its reasoning is what the Revenue can be expected to rely on. A firm that treats a partner’s fees as outside section 35(e) is therefore relying on principle, not on a decided case.

Goods are different from services

A purchase of goods from the partner’s own business is not salary, bonus, commission, remuneration or interest, so section 35(e) does not apply to it and the firm claims the cost in the usual way. It is still a payment to a specified person (a related party), so section 36 applies. If the Assessing Officer considers the expenditure excessive or unreasonable compared with the fair market value of the goods, the legitimate needs of the business or the benefit derived, that part is not allowed (section 36(2)).

For a firm, a partner is a “specified person”, and so is any person carrying on a business or profession in which a partner has a substantial interest, which means a right to at least 20% of its profits (section 36(3)). A partner’s own proprietary business is therefore covered. Selling to the firm at the price he charges other customers answers the test. So does paying by bank: payments of more than ₹10,000 in a day to one person that do not go through a bank or a specified online mode are generally not deductible (section 36(4)).

Services are the harder case. A fee for services looks more like remuneration, because the partner is being paid for his own work.

Two ways the fee can be treated

View How the fee is treated Deduction for the firm Main risk
The fee is an outside business expense Business expenditure under section 34, tested for reasonableness under section 36 Allowed in full if it is reasonable The Revenue treats it as remuneration, because the partner is paid for his work and the section covers remuneration “by whatever name called”
The fee is remuneration to a working partner Part of the partners’ remuneration under section 35(e) Allowed only if the deed authorises it and the total stays within the limit Anything above the limit is disallowed, and the whole fee can be disallowed if the deed does not authorise it

Worked example: same facts, two views

Take a firm whose working partners are paid ₹10,00,000 as remuneration under the deed, with a further ₹6,00,000 of fees paid to one of them. Profit before deducting any partner remuneration and before the fee is ₹20,00,000.

Item Fee treated as remuneration Fee treated as a business expense
Profit before partner remuneration and the fee ₹20,00,000 ₹20,00,000
Book profit for the limit ₹20,00,000 (the fee is added back) ₹14,00,000 (the fee stays deducted)
Limit on remuneration (90% of the first ₹6,00,000 plus 60% of the balance) ₹13,80,000 ₹10,20,000
Remuneration counted against the limit ₹16,00,000 ₹10,00,000
Disallowed under section 35(e) ₹2,20,000 Nil (the fee is still tested under section 36)

The second view gives the firm more room here, but it also lowers the book profit, and with it the limit, by the amount of the fee. When the book profit is above ₹6,00,000, the limit works out at 60% of the book profit plus ₹1,80,000, which gives a quick test. If the profit before partner remuneration and the fee had been ₹30,00,000, both views would allow everything, with limits of ₹19,80,000 and ₹16,20,000. Under the first view, the disallowed amount is added to the firm’s income and taxed at the firm’s rate, with interest on the extra tax.

How to build the case that the fee is outside section 35(e)

A firm that wants to take this position should be able to show that the partner is paid as an independent professional and not for working in the firm:

  1. A separate engagement letter before the work starts, with the scope, deliverables, fee and date, approved by the other partners.
  2. A genuine independent practice: other clients served at the same rates, its own registration (for example under GST), premises or staff, bank account and books.
  3. Evidence of the market rate: invoices to unrelated clients for similar work.
  4. Work that is not part of his duties as a working partner, and no second claim for the same work as normal remuneration.
  5. A proper invoice, paid through the bank, with tax deducted at source under the right item (see below).
  6. Not a captive supplier: if the firm is most of his practice, the independent label weakens.

None of this makes the argument a settled one, but it is the evidence that gives it the best chance.

The safer plan: make the fee fit under the limit

Because the outside view is untested for services, the safer plan is to make sure that the fee, added to the partners’ normal remuneration, fits within the limit, so that the label does not matter. Before the tax year begins:

  1. Estimate the book profit and the limit, as in the example above.
  2. Compare the limit with the normal remuneration plus the fee. If the limit is enough, both views give the same result.
  3. Amend the partnership deed before the year starts. Remuneration that is not authorised by the deed applicable for the period, or that relates to a period before the date of the deed, is not deductible (section 35(e)(ii)). For tax year 2027-28 (01/04/2027 to 31/03/2028) the deed should be signed by 31/03/2027.
  4. State the amount or the method in the deed. The Revenue has long relied on CBDT Circular 739 of 25/03/1996, which wants the deed to fix each working partner’s remuneration or the way it is worked out. The Himachal Pradesh High Court held in Durga Dass Devki Nandan v. ITO (11/03/2011) that the circular goes beyond the section, but the Delhi Tribunal upheld a disallowance in Sood Brij & Associates v. JCIT (29/10/2010) where the deed did not state the total remuneration or the partners’ shares. The circular was issued under the 1961 Act, and we have not checked whether it has been carried over to the 2025 Act. Stating the amount or the method costs nothing and removes the argument.
  5. Keep the engagement letter and the evidence listed above anyway. They support either view.

Tax deducted at source and GST

  • TDS: If the payment is treated as fees for professional or technical services, the firm deducts tax under section 393(1), Table Sl. No. 6(iii) (old section 194J): 10%, or 2% for technical services that are not professional services, above the threshold in the table. If it is treated as a sum in the nature of remuneration paid to a partner, section 393(3), Table Sl. No. 7 (old section 194T) applies at 10% above ₹20,000. Our TDS rate chart under section 393 gives the table. Use the same treatment in the TDS return and in the returns of the firm and the partner.
  • GST: A partner who is registered under GST and bills the firm for services issues a tax invoice and charges GST in the usual way. This post does not cover the GST rules, so confirm the rate and the input tax credit position separately.

Make the partner’s return match

Salary, bonus, commission or remuneration that a partner receives from the firm is not treated as salary (section 15(4)). The part that is allowed to the firm under section 35(e) is business income of the partner (section 26(1)(g)). If the firm’s deduction is later cut, the partner’s assessment can be amended to remove the matching income, within the time limit in section 288 (Table Sl. No. 1).

If the partner has reported the same sum as ordinary professional income instead, that route may not fit, so the firm and the partner should settle the treatment together before either return is filed.

What we have and have not checked

We read the Income-tax Act, 2025 as amended by the Finance Act 2026, and the judgments linked below. In our search of reported decisions available online we found none that decides whether fees for an independent professional practice paid to a partner are outside section 35(e). The law can change with the next Finance Act, so recheck it before acting.

How CSM & Co LLP can help

We draft and update partnership deeds, compute book profit and partner remuneration, review related-party payments and file the returns of firms and partners. Please reach out to our team and we will be happy to assist.

Frequently asked questions

Does section 35(e) apply to professional fees paid to a partner?

The section does not mention professional fees. It applies to expenditure “in the nature of” salary, bonus, commission or remuneration, by whatever name called, paid to a partner. Whether fees for separate professional services count is not settled: we found no reported judgment of the Supreme Court or a High Court that decides it, and the Supreme Court has held, for a commission, that a separate contract does not take the payment outside the old section 40(b). Plan on the basis that the fee may be treated as remuneration.

What is the limit on partners’ remuneration?

The total remuneration to all working partners, as authorised by the partnership deed, is allowed up to: on the first ₹6,00,000 of book profit, ₹3,00,000 in case of a loss or 90% of the book profit, whichever is higher; and on the balance of the book profit, 60% (section 35(e)(iii)). When the book profit is above ₹6,00,000, this works out at 60% of the book profit plus ₹1,80,000.

Does the partnership deed settle the matter if it allows the fee?

No. Authorisation by the deed is one condition for deducting remuneration (section 35(e)(ii)), and the total must also stay within the limit (section 35(e)(iii)). In Rashiklal and Co. the commission was paid under a separate agreement, and the Supreme Court still held that it was not deductible under the old section 40(b).

Can a firm buy goods from a partner’s own business?

Section 35(e) does not list purchases of goods, so the cost is claimed in the usual way. The firm must be able to show that the price is at market rate, because a payment to a partner, or to a business in which a partner has a right to at least 20% of the profits, can be disallowed to the extent it is excessive or unreasonable (section 36(2) and (3)). As a rule, payments of more than ₹10,000 in a day to one person must go through a bank or a specified online mode (section 36(4)).

What happens if the deduction is disallowed?

The disallowed amount is added to the firm’s income and taxed at the firm’s rate, with interest. The partner’s side must match: remuneration from the firm is business income of the partner only to the extent allowed to the firm (section 26(1)(g)), and his assessment can be amended if the firm’s deduction is later cut (section 288, Table Sl. No. 1). If the partner has reported the same sum as ordinary professional income, that route may not fit, so settle the treatment before both returns are filed.

How is tax deducted at source on the payment?

If it is treated as fees for professional or technical services, section 393(1), Table Sl. No. 6(iii) applies (old section 194J): 10%, or 2% for technical services that are not professional services, above the threshold in the table. If it is treated as a sum in the nature of remuneration paid to a partner, section 393(3), Table Sl. No. 7 applies (old section 194T): 10% above ₹20,000. Use the same treatment in the TDS return and in the returns of the firm and the partner.

By when should the partnership deed be changed?

Before the tax year to which the payment relates. Remuneration that is not authorised by the deed applicable for the period, or that relates to a period before the date of the deed, is not deductible (section 35(e)(ii)). For tax year 2027-28, which runs from 01/04/2027 to 31/03/2028, the deed should be signed by 31/03/2027.

Official sources

Related reading

Disclaimer

This article is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered professional advice. Please consult a qualified expert for advice tailored to your specific situation. The author and website owner are not liable for any errors or actions based on this content.

ITR Filing Deadline for AY 2026-27 Extended to 21 November 2026 for Audit Cases

Last updated: 28 September 2026 · Reading time: 5 min

Quick summary

  • ITR filing due date for AY 2026-27 (audit cases) extended from 31 October 2026 to 21 November 2026.
  • Tax audit report specified date extended from 30 September 2026 to 21 October 2026.
  • Applies only to taxpayers whose accounts require audit under the Income-tax Act, 1961.
  • Taxpayers not covered under audit continue to follow their original due dates.

The Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) has, vide Circular No. 7/2026 dated 28 September 2026 (F. No. 225/128/2026/ITA-II), extended the due date for filing Income Tax Returns for Assessment Year 2026-27, for taxpayers covered under clause (a) of Explanation 2 to sub-section (1) of Section 139 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, that is, taxpayers whose accounts are required to be audited.

Correspondingly, the specified date for furnishing the tax audit report for AY 2026-27 has also been extended. This gives audit cases extra time to complete the audit and file the return, but the timeline still needs to be planned carefully so nothing is rushed in the final week.

Notification at a glance

  • Assessment Year: 2026-27
  • Issued by: Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT)
  • ITR filing due date: extended from 31 October 2026 to 21 November 2026
  • Tax audit report specified date: extended from 30 September 2026 to 21 October 2026
  • Coverage: persons mentioned at S. No. 2 in the table below Explanation 2 to Section 139(1), that is, taxpayers whose accounts require audit
  • Official circular: Circular No. 7/2026 (PDF), Income Tax Department, Government of India
  • Source announcement: Income Tax India, official post

Revised due dates for AY 2026-27

Compliance Original due date Extended due date
Tax audit report (Section 44AB) 30 September 2026 21 October 2026
ITR filing, audit cases (Section 139(1)) 31 October 2026 21 November 2026

Who this applies to

This extension covers taxpayers whose accounts are required to be audited under the Income-tax Act, 1961, including companies, and individuals, firms and LLPs subject to tax audit under Section 44AB. It does not apply to taxpayers who are not covered under this audit provision, including most salaried individuals and small taxpayers filing ITR-1 or ITR-4; their original due date of 31 July 2026 (or as otherwise notified) remains unchanged.

Employer and taxpayer action checklist

  • Complete the audit first. Use the window up to 21 October 2026 to finish the statutory audit, finalise books, reconciliations and supporting schedules.
  • File the audit report on time. The tax audit report under Section 44AB must be uploaded by 21 October 2026, since the ITR cannot be filed correctly without it.
  • Do not wait till the last date to file the ITR. Once the audit report is filed, file the return at the earliest, rather than waiting until 21 November 2026.
  • Reconcile TDS and GST data in advance. Match Form 26AS, AIS and GSTR data with your books before filing, so the return is not revised later.
  • Keep pending notices and demands in hand. Any outstanding income tax notices should be addressed before filing, not after.

Consequences of missing the extended date

The extension applies only to the compliance dates listed above. If the ITR is still not filed by 21 November 2026 for an audit case, the usual late-filing consequences under the Income-tax Act, 1961 apply, including a late fee under Section 234F, interest under Section 234A on any unpaid tax, and denial of certain deductions and set-off of losses. Filing well ahead of the extended date is the only way to avoid this risk entirely.

Frequently asked questions

Does this extension apply to all taxpayers?

No. It applies only to taxpayers whose accounts require audit under the Income-tax Act, 1961, for AY 2026-27. Non-audit taxpayers must continue to follow their original due date.

Has the due date for non-audit taxpayers also changed?

No. This notification does not change the due date for individuals and entities not covered under the tax audit provisions.

Can the tax audit report be filed after 21 October 2026?

No. 21 October 2026 is now the specified date for furnishing the tax audit report for AY 2026-27. Filing it late attracts penalty under Section 271B, separately from any ITR late-filing consequence.

Should I still pay advance tax or self-assessment tax on time even though the filing date is extended?

Yes. The extension is for the return and audit report filing dates only. Any unpaid tax continues to attract interest under the applicable provisions if not paid before the original timelines.

Could the date be extended further?

CBDT has extended ITR due dates in past years closer to the original deadline as well. CSM & Co LLP will track any further CBDT notification and update clients directly if the date changes again, but it is safer to plan around 21 November 2026 rather than expect another extension.

How CSM & Co LLP can help

At CSM & Co LLP, Chartered Accountants, we handle tax audits, ITR filing and compliance tracking for businesses and professionals across Gujarat. As part of this, we regularly help clients with:

  • Completing the statutory tax audit and filing Form 3CA/3CB-3CD well before the specified date
  • Reconciling TDS credits, GST turnover and books before the return is filed
  • Filing the Income Tax Return accurately for companies, firms, LLPs and individuals subject to audit
  • Tracking CBDT notifications and deadline changes on your behalf, so nothing is missed

Please reach out to our team and we will be happy to assist.

Disclaimer

This article is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered professional advice. Please consult a qualified expert for advice tailored to your specific situation. The author and website owner are not liable for any errors or actions based on this content.

Switching Into or Out of the GST Composition Scheme (2026): ITC-03, ITC-01 and Rule 44

Last updated: 18 September 2026 · Written and reviewed by CA Meet Dhrangadhariya, CSM & Co LLP

Quick summary

  • Switching from regular GST to the Composition Scheme means paying back the input tax credit on stock and capital goods held on the day before the switch, in FORM GST ITC-03, within 60 days of the start of the financial year.
  • Switching back from the Composition Scheme to regular GST means the opposite: input tax credit on stock and capital goods can be claimed again, in FORM GST ITC-01, within 30 days of becoming eligible.
  • Capital goods credit is not reversed or reclaimed in full - it is reduced by 5 percentage points for every quarter (or part of a quarter) since the invoice date.
  • A claim in FORM GST ITC-01 above Rs 2 lakh needs certification by a practising Chartered Accountant or Cost Accountant.
  • These rules sit in section 18 of the CGST Act and rules 3, 40 and 44 of the CGST Rules, separate from the quarterly CMP-08 and annual GSTR-4 compliance covered in our main Composition Scheme guide.

Our main guide to the Composition Scheme covers who can opt in, the flat rates, and the CMP-02/CMP-08/GSTR-4 compliance cycle. This post covers a narrower question that trips up almost every business making the switch either way: what happens to the input tax credit already sitting in your books?

New to GST terms such as “input tax credit” or “electronic credit ledger”? See the technical terms explained in simple words further down.

Why the switch matters for input tax credit

A composition dealer pays a flat rate of tax out of pocket and is not entitled to input tax credit at all. A regular taxpayer is entitled to credit on most purchases. The moment a business crosses from one status to the other, the law has to settle what happens to credit already claimed, or not yet claimed, on stock and capital assets sitting in the business on that date. Section 18 of the CGST Act, 2017 (Availability of credit in special circumstances) governs both directions.

Switching from regular GST to the Composition Scheme: pay back the credit

Under section 18(4) of the CGST Act, a registered person who has availed input tax credit and then opts to pay tax under section 10 (the Composition Scheme) must pay an amount equal to the credit of input tax on:

  • inputs held in stock,
  • inputs contained in semi-finished or finished goods held in stock, and
  • capital goods,

as they stood on the day immediately preceding the date of exercising the option. This amount is paid by debit to the electronic credit ledger or electronic cash ledger. Any balance of input tax credit left in the ledger after this payment lapses - it cannot be carried forward or refunded.

FORM GST ITC-03 and the 60 day limit

Rule 3(3) of the CGST Rules requires every registered person opting for the Composition Scheme to file FORM GST CMP-02 before the start of the financial year, and to furnish the stock and credit-reversal statement in FORM GST ITC-03 within 60 days from the commencement of the relevant financial year, calculated in the manner set out in rule 44(4).

Switching from the Composition Scheme back to regular GST: reclaim the credit

The reverse move is covered by section 18(1)(c) of the CGST Act. Where a registered person ceases to pay tax under section 10 (voluntarily, or because turnover crosses the limit), they become entitled to take credit of input tax on:

  • inputs held in stock,
  • inputs contained in semi-finished or finished goods held in stock, and
  • capital goods,

as they stood on the day immediately preceding the date from which they become liable to pay tax under section 9 (the normal levy).

FORM GST ITC-01 and the 30 day limit

Rule 40 of the CGST Rules requires this claim to be made electronically in FORM GST ITC-01, within 30 days of becoming eligible to avail the credit (or such further period as the Commissioner allows by notification).

  • The declaration must give full details of the stock or capital goods it relates to, as on the relevant day.
  • If the aggregate claim across central tax, State tax, Union territory tax and integrated tax exceeds Rs 2 lakh, it must be certified by a practising Chartered Accountant or Cost Accountant.
  • The claim on inputs is verified against the corresponding supplier’s FORM GSTR-1 (and FORM GSTR-1A, where filed) or FORM GSTR-4, on the common portal.

Capital goods are never credited or reversed at full value

Both directions work out to the same depreciation-style result, though the two rules word it differently. Rule 40(1)(a), for claiming credit back, says it directly:

The input tax credit on capital goods is calculated by reducing the tax originally paid on those capital goods by 5 percentage points for every quarter of a year, or part of a quarter, counted from the date of the invoice (or other receipt document) for those capital goods.

Rule 44(1)(b), for reversing credit on the way into the scheme, is worded in months rather than quarters: the credit is reduced pro-rata over a five-year (60-month) useful life, based on the remaining useful life in months on the date of the switch. The two formulas land on the same number, since 1/60th a month for three months is the same 5% that Rule 40 states directly per quarter - so the worked example below holds either way, even though Rule 44 itself never uses the words “5 percentage points per quarter”.

In practice, this means a capital asset invoiced a long time before the switch carries little or no credit to reverse or reclaim by the time 20 quarters (5 years, or 60 months) have passed, since the credit base is fully used up by then under either rule’s wording.

A worked example

A trader buys machinery for Rs 10 lakh plus Rs 1.8 lakh GST (18%) and claims the full Rs 1.8 lakh as input tax credit. Fourteen months (five completed quarters) later, the trader opts into the Composition Scheme.

Step Amount
Original input tax credit on the machinery Rs 1,80,000
Reduction: 5 percentage points x 5 quarters = 25% Rs 45,000
Credit to be reversed in FORM GST ITC-03 Rs 1,35,000

The same 5-percentage-points-per-quarter formula would apply in reverse if the trader later opted back into regular GST and reclaimed credit on the same machinery in FORM GST ITC-01, counted from the invoice date, not from the date of the earlier reversal.

How CSM & Co LLP can help

Getting the ITC-03 or ITC-01 timing and valuation wrong is one of the most common, and most expensive, mistakes businesses make when switching GST status - a missed 60 day or 30 day deadline, or an uncertified claim above Rs 2 lakh, can turn into a dispute with the department later. Please reach out to our team and we will be happy to help with the stock valuation, the filing, and the CA certification where required.

Technical terms explained in simple words

Term What it means
Input tax credit The GST a business already paid on its purchases, which it can normally subtract from the GST it collects on its sales.
Electronic credit ledger The online account on the GST Portal that holds a taxpayer’s available input tax credit.
Electronic cash ledger The online account on the GST Portal that holds a taxpayer’s cash deposited for paying GST.
Capital goods Goods such as machinery or equipment used in the business over several years, as opposed to goods bought for resale or immediate use.
FORM GST ITC-03 The form used to declare and pay back input tax credit when switching into the Composition Scheme or when supplies become wholly exempt.
FORM GST ITC-01 The form used to claim back input tax credit when switching out of the Composition Scheme, on fresh registration, or when exempt supplies become taxable.
Quarter (for this calculation) A three-month block counted from the capital good’s invoice date, used only to work out how much of its credit has “worn off” for this reversal or claim - not a calendar quarter.

Frequently asked questions

What happens to input tax credit when I switch from regular GST to the Composition Scheme?

You must pay back, by debit to your electronic credit or cash ledger, an amount equal to the input tax credit on inputs held in stock, inputs in semi-finished or finished goods, and on capital goods, as they stood on the day before the switch. Any input tax credit left in your ledger after that payment lapses.

Which form is used to reverse this credit?

FORM GST ITC-03, filed within 60 days of the start of the financial year for which you opt into the scheme, as required by rule 3(3) of the CGST Rules.

What happens to input tax credit when I switch back from the Composition Scheme to regular GST?

You become entitled to claim input tax credit again, on inputs held in stock, inputs in semi-finished or finished goods, and on capital goods, as they stood on the day before you became liable to pay tax under section 9.

Which form is used to reclaim this credit?

FORM GST ITC-01, filed within 30 days of becoming eligible to avail the credit, under rule 40 of the CGST Rules.

How is the credit on capital goods calculated, since they are not new?

It is reduced by 5 percentage points for every quarter, or part of a quarter, that has passed since the date of the invoice for that capital good - not reversed or reclaimed at the full original amount.

Does a FORM GST ITC-01 claim need certification?

Yes, if the aggregate claim across central tax, State tax, Union territory tax and integrated tax exceeds Rs 2 lakh, the declaration must be certified by a practising Chartered Accountant or Cost Accountant.

Official sources

Disclaimer

This article is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered professional advice. Please consult a qualified expert for advice tailored to your specific situation. The author and website owner are not liable for any errors or actions based on this content.

Audit Committee, Nomination and Remuneration Committee and Vigil Mechanism under Sections 177 and 178 of the Companies Act, 2013

Last updated: 09 October 2026 · Written and reviewed by CA Meet Dhrangadhariya, CSM & Co LLP

Quick summary

  • Every listed public company, and the prescribed classes, must have an Audit Committee of at least three directors with independent directors in the majority. Its terms of reference cover auditors, financial statements, related party approval, inter-corporate loans, valuation, internal financial controls and use of funds raised.
  • The Nomination and Remuneration Committee has three or more non-executive directors, at least half independent, and recommends director and senior management appointments, board evaluation and remuneration policy.
  • A Stakeholders Relationship Committee is needed where a company has more than 1,000 security holders at any time in a financial year.
  • A vigil mechanism is required for listed companies and prescribed classes. Contravention carries a fine of Rs 1 lakh to Rs 5 lakh on the company and Rs 1 lakh on each officer in default.

Larger and listed companies must hand some of the Board’s most sensitive work to committees dominated by independent directors. Section 177 sets up the Audit Committee and the vigil mechanism; section 178 sets up the Nomination and Remuneration Committee and the Stakeholders Relationship Committee.

Audit Committee (section 177)

Who must have one. The Board of every listed public company, and of such other classes of companies as may be prescribed, constitutes an Audit Committee.

Composition. A minimum of three directors, with independent directors forming a majority. The majority of members, including the chairperson, must have the ability to read and understand a financial statement.

Terms of reference. The committee acts under written terms of reference set by the Board, which include:

  1. recommending the appointment, remuneration and terms of appointment of auditors;
  2. reviewing and monitoring the auditor’s independence and performance, and the effectiveness of the audit process;
  3. examining the financial statement and the auditors’ report on it;
  4. approval or any subsequent modification of transactions with related parties. The committee may give omnibus approval subject to prescribed conditions. If a transaction (other than one under section 188) is not approved, the committee makes its recommendation to the Board. If a transaction not exceeding Rs 1 crore is entered into by a director or officer without the committee’s approval and is not ratified within three months, it is voidable at the committee’s option, and the director concerned must indemnify the company where it is with a related party or was authorised by another director. This does not apply to transactions, other than those under section 188, between a holding company and its wholly owned subsidiary;
  5. scrutiny of inter-corporate loans and investments;
  6. valuation of undertakings or assets of the company, wherever necessary;
  7. evaluation of internal financial controls and risk management systems; and
  8. monitoring the end use of funds raised through public offers and related matters.

Powers. It can call for the auditors’ comments on internal control systems and the scope of the audit, review financial statements before they go to the Board, discuss issues with internal and statutory auditors and management, investigate any matter within its terms of reference or referred by the Board, obtain professional advice from external sources, and has full access to the company’s records. The auditors and the KMP have a right to be heard in the committee’s meetings when the auditor’s report is considered, but no right to vote.

Disclosure. The Board’s report discloses the composition of the Audit Committee and, where the Board did not accept any recommendation of the committee, that fact with the reasons.

Vigil mechanism (section 177(9) and (10))

Every listed company and the prescribed classes must establish a vigil mechanism for directors and employees to report genuine concerns, in the prescribed manner. It must have adequate safeguards against victimisation of the persons who use it, and direct access to the chairperson of the Audit Committee in appropriate or exceptional cases. The details are disclosed on the company’s website (if any) and in the Board’s report.

Nomination and Remuneration Committee (section 178(1) to (4))

Who must have one. The Board of every listed public company, and of the prescribed classes.

Composition. Three or more non-executive directors, of whom not less than one-half are independent directors. The chairperson of the company, whether executive or non-executive, may be a member but shall not chair the committee.

Functions.

  • Identify persons qualified to become directors and persons who may be appointed in senior management under the laid-down criteria, and recommend to the Board their appointment and removal.
  • Specify the manner of effective evaluation of the performance of the Board, its committees and individual directors, to be carried out by the Board, by the committee or by an independent external agency, and review its implementation and compliance.
  • Formulate the criteria for determining qualifications, positive attributes and independence of a director, and recommend to the Board a remuneration policy for directors, KMP and other employees.

Policy safeguards. The remuneration policy must ensure that (a) the level and composition of remuneration is reasonable and sufficient to attract, retain and motivate directors of the quality required; (b) the relationship of remuneration to performance is clear and meets appropriate benchmarks; and (c) remuneration to directors, KMP and senior management is a balance between fixed and incentive pay reflecting short and long-term performance objectives. The policy is placed on the company’s website (if any), and its salient features and changes, with the web address, are disclosed in the Board’s report.

“Senior management” means the core management team excluding the Board, comprising all members of management one level below the executive directors, including functional heads.

Stakeholders Relationship Committee (section 178(5) and (6))

A company with more than one thousand shareholders, debenture-holders, deposit-holders and other security holders at any time during a financial year constitutes a Stakeholders Relationship Committee. Its chairperson is a non-executive director, and the Board decides the other members. It considers and resolves the grievances of security holders. The inability to resolve or consider a grievance in good faith is not a contravention.

Attendance and penalty

  • The chairperson of each committee, or any member authorised by him, attends the general meetings of the company (section 178(7)).
  • Penalty (section 178(8)): for contravention of section 177 or section 178, the company is punishable with a fine of not less than Rs 1 lakh, up to Rs 5 lakh, and every officer in default is liable to a penalty of Rs 1 lakh, as the section reads after the 2020 amendment (the India Code print of the amended words is repetitive, so confirm the figure against the latest official text).

A short checklist

  1. Test whether your company is a listed public company or in a prescribed class; if so, set up the committees by Board resolution with written terms of reference.
  2. Check the composition rules: three directors with an independent majority for audit; three non-executive directors with at least half independent for nomination and remuneration.
  3. Put the vigil mechanism policy on the website and mention it in the Board’s report.
  4. Count security holders each year against the 1,000 threshold.
  5. Record in the Board’s report the composition of the Audit Committee and any recommendation of that committee which the Board did not accept.

Points to check

  • This post follows the Companies Act as published on India Code, including its amendments up to the footnotes in that edition. The prescribed classes of companies for each committee, the omnibus approval conditions and the vigil mechanism rules are in the Rules, which were not reviewed.
  • Listed companies must also follow the SEBI listing regulations, which add further requirements on the number of meetings, independent directors and the role of each committee.
  • The India Code print of section 178(8) repeats the penalty words after the 2020 substitution. This post reads it as a fine of Rs 1 lakh to Rs 5 lakh on the company and Rs 1 lakh on each officer in default, and that reading should be confirmed.

Frequently asked questions

Which companies must have an Audit Committee?

Every listed public company, and other classes of companies prescribed by the Rules. It must have at least three directors, with independent directors forming a majority. The majority of members, including the chairperson, must be able to read and understand a financial statement.

What does the Audit Committee do?

It acts under written terms of reference set by the Board, which include recommending the appointment, remuneration and terms of auditors; reviewing the auditor’s independence, performance and effectiveness of the audit; examining the financial statements and the auditors’ report; approving related party transactions; scrutinising inter-corporate loans and investments; valuation of undertakings or assets; evaluating internal financial controls and risk management; and monitoring the end use of funds raised through public offers.

Can the Audit Committee approve related party transactions in advance?

Yes. It may make omnibus approval for related party transactions proposed to be entered into, subject to the prescribed conditions.

Who must have a Nomination and Remuneration Committee?

Every listed public company and the prescribed classes. It consists of three or more non-executive directors, not less than one-half of them independent. The chairperson of the company may be a member but cannot chair the committee.

When is a Stakeholders Relationship Committee required?

When the company has more than 1,000 shareholders, debenture-holders, deposit-holders and other security holders at any time in a financial year. Its chairperson must be a non-executive director, and it considers and resolves the grievances of security holders.

What is a vigil mechanism?

A mechanism for directors and employees to report genuine concerns, which every listed company and the prescribed classes must establish. It must protect users from victimisation and give direct access to the chairperson of the Audit Committee in appropriate or exceptional cases. Its details are disclosed on the company’s website and in the Board’s report.

What is the penalty for contravention?

A fine of not less than Rs 1 lakh, up to Rs 5 lakh on the company, and a penalty of Rs 1 lakh on every officer in default (as the section reads after the 2020 amendment).

Official sources

Disclaimer

This article is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered professional advice. Please consult a qualified expert for advice tailored to your specific situation. The author and website owner are not liable for any errors or actions based on this content.

GST Composition Scheme (2026): Turnover Limit, Rate, CMP-02 and Returns

Last updated: 19 October 2026 · Written and reviewed by CA Meet Dhrangadhariya, CSM & Co LLP

Quick summary

  • A trader or manufacturer with turnover up to Rs 1.5 crore (Rs 75 lakh in the North-Eastern states and Himachal Pradesh) can opt for the Composition Scheme and pay tax at a flat 1 percent of turnover instead of the regular rate.
  • A composition dealer cannot claim input tax credit, cannot make inter-state supplies, and cannot issue a tax invoice; a Bill of Supply is used instead.
  • The scheme is opted for every year on the GST Portal in FORM GST CMP-02, before the financial year begins.
  • Tax is paid quarterly in FORM GST CMP-08, and the annual return GSTR-4 is due by 30th June of the following financial year.
  • A separate scheme at 6 percent lets service providers (and mixed suppliers) with turnover up to Rs 50 lakh opt in under section 10(2A).

The Composition Scheme under GST exists so that a small trader, manufacturer or restaurant does not have to deal with the full set of GST compliance: a tax invoice for every sale, input tax credit reconciliation, and a monthly return. In exchange for that simplicity, a composition dealer pays a flat, low rate of tax on total turnover and gives up input tax credit.

New to GST terms such as “input tax credit” or “tax invoice”? See the technical terms explained in simple words further down.

Who can opt for the Composition Scheme

Under Section 10 of the CGST Act, 2017, confirmed on the CBIC Tax Information Portal, a registered person can opt for the scheme if their aggregate turnover in the preceding financial year does not exceed:

Category Turnover limit
General category states Rs 1.5 crore
North-Eastern states and Himachal Pradesh Rs 75 lakh
Service providers and mixed suppliers (section 10(2A)) Rs 50 lakh

Aggregate turnover is computed across all businesses registered under the same PAN, not for one GSTIN alone.

A manufacturer or trader who opts under section 10(1) can also supply services up to 10 percent of turnover, or Rs 5 lakh, whichever is higher, without losing eligibility.

Who cannot opt for the Composition Scheme

  • A manufacturer of ice cream, pan masala or tobacco (goods notified as ineligible).
  • A person making inter-state outward supplies.
  • A casual taxable person or a non-resident taxable person.
  • A person supplying goods through an e-commerce operator who is required to collect tax at source under section 52.
  • A supplier of goods that are not taxable under GST, such as alcohol for human consumption.
  • Any other class of person or goods notified by the Government on the recommendation of the GST Council.

Conditions a composition dealer must follow

  • No input tax credit can be claimed on inward supplies.
  • Tax must be paid at normal rates, not the composition rate, on supplies received under the Reverse Charge Mechanism.
  • Where a taxable person runs more than one business vertical under the same PAN, every vertical must be registered under the scheme together, or the option is not available.
  • The words “composition taxable person, not eligible to collect tax on supplies” must be displayed on every notice or signboard at the place of business, and at the top of every Bill of Supply.

How to opt in: FORM GST CMP-02

A taxpayer already registered as a regular dealer opts in by filing FORM GST CMP-02 online on the GST Portal, under Services, then Registration, then Application to Opt for Composition Levy. This intimation is filed once at the start of the financial year for which the option is to apply, and stays in force for later years unless the dealer opts out or becomes ineligible.

A person applying for a fresh GST registration can choose the composition option at the time of registration itself, without filing CMP-02 separately.

Rate of tax under the Composition Scheme

Section 10 of the CGST Act caps the composition rate; the actual rate charged is prescribed by Rule 7 of the CGST Rules, 2017, verified directly on the CBIC Tax Information Portal:

Type of business CGST SGST Total
Manufacturers and traders of goods 0.5% 0.5% 1.0%
Restaurants not serving alcohol 2.5% 2.5% 5.0%
Service providers and mixed suppliers (section 10(2A)) 3.0% 3.0% 6.0%

The tax is calculated on total turnover of the quarter, not on a value-added or margin basis, and is paid by the dealer out of pocket - it cannot be collected from the customer.

How a composition dealer bills a customer

A composition dealer cannot issue a tax invoice, because GST is never charged to the customer. Instead, a Bill of Supply is issued, carrying the words “composition taxable person, not eligible to collect tax on supplies” at the top.

Returns and payment

Form What it is Due date
FORM GST CMP-08 Quarterly statement-cum-payment of tax 18th of the month after the quarter ends
FORM GSTR-4 Annual return 30th June following the end of the financial year

A composition dealer is not required to maintain the detailed records that a regular taxpayer must keep, and does not file the monthly GSTR-1/GSTR-3B cycle.

Opting out

A dealer who crosses the turnover limit, starts an ineligible activity, or simply wants to move back to regular GST must file FORM GST CMP-04 on the GST Portal, intimating withdrawal from the scheme, after which normal GST provisions (tax invoices, input tax credit, monthly returns) apply from the date of withdrawal.

Advantages and disadvantages

Advantages
– Lower compliance: one annual return instead of monthly filings, and simpler record-keeping.
– A fixed, low rate of tax, which keeps cash flow predictable for a small business.
– No need to track input tax credit on every purchase.

Disadvantages
– No input tax credit on purchases, which can raise the effective cost of inputs.
– No inter-state sales and no sales through an e-commerce operator that collects tax at source.
– Customers who are themselves GST-registered cannot claim any credit on their purchase from a composition dealer, which can make the dealer a less attractive supplier to a GST-registered buyer.

How CSM & Co LLP can help

Choosing between the Composition Scheme and regular GST registration depends on your customer mix, margins and growth plans, not turnover alone. Please reach out to our team and we will be happy to assist with the comparison, the CMP-02 filing, and the quarterly and annual compliance that follows.

Technical terms explained in simple words

Term What it means
Aggregate turnover The total value of all taxable, exempt and export supplies made under one PAN, across all its GST registrations, counted together.
Input tax credit The GST a business already paid on its purchases, which it can normally subtract from the GST it collects on its sales. A composition dealer gives this up.
Tax invoice The GST-charging bill a regular dealer issues, showing the tax separately so the buyer can claim credit.
Bill of Supply The bill a composition dealer issues instead of a tax invoice, since no GST is shown or charged to the buyer.
Reverse Charge Mechanism A situation where the buyer, not the seller, has to pay GST directly to the Government on a purchase.
FORM GST CMP-02 The online form used to opt into the Composition Scheme for a financial year.
FORM GST CMP-04 The online form used to opt out of the Composition Scheme.
FORM GST CMP-08 The quarterly form on which a composition dealer pays its tax.
GSTR-4 The annual return a composition dealer files summing up the year’s turnover and tax paid.

Frequently asked questions

Who can opt for the GST Composition Scheme?

A trader, manufacturer or restaurant (not serving alcohol) whose aggregate turnover in the preceding financial year was up to Rs 1.5 crore (Rs 75 lakh in the North-Eastern states and Himachal Pradesh), and who meets the conditions under section 10 of the CGST Act.

Who cannot opt for the Composition Scheme?

A manufacturer of ice cream, pan masala or tobacco, a person making inter-state outward supplies or supplying goods through an e-commerce operator required to collect tax at source, a casual taxable person, a non-resident taxable person, and any person or goods notified by the Government on the Council’s recommendation.

What is the GST rate under the Composition Scheme?

1 percent of turnover for manufacturers and traders of goods, 5 percent for restaurants not serving alcohol, and 6 percent for other eligible service providers and mixed suppliers opting under section 10(2A).

How does a taxpayer opt for the scheme?

By filing FORM GST CMP-02 online on the GST Portal, under Services, then Registration, then Application to Opt for Composition Levy, before the start of the financial year for which the option is to apply.

Can a composition dealer claim input tax credit or issue a tax invoice?

No. A composition dealer cannot claim input tax credit on purchases and cannot charge GST to customers, so a Bill of Supply is issued instead of a tax invoice, marked “composition taxable person, not eligible to collect tax on supplies”.

What returns does a composition dealer file?

A quarterly tax payment in FORM GST CMP-08, due by the 18th of the month after the quarter ends, and an annual return in FORM GSTR-4, due by 30th June following the end of the financial year.

Official sources

Related reading

Disclaimer

This article is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered professional advice. Please consult a qualified expert for advice tailored to your specific situation. The author and website owner are not liable for any errors or actions based on this content.

The Supplier Is Genuine. So How Can the Payment Still Be Fraudulent?

 When a Genuine Invoice Leads to a Fraudulent Payment

A supplier may be completely genuine.

The invoice may be genuine.
The goods or services may have actually been received.
The purchase may have been properly approved.
And the payment amount may exactly match the invoice.

Yet, the payment can still be fraudulent.

How?

The risk is not always the supplier. It can be the bank account.

Consider a simple situation.

A company regularly purchases goods from a genuine supplier. The supplier’s name, GST details, invoices and transactions all appear legitimate.

At some point, the supplier’s bank account details are changed in the company’s records.

The new bank account may have been inserted or changed by someone within the accounts or finance process.

The payment is then made to the new account.

From the accounting records, everything may appear normal:

  • Genuine supplier
  • Genuine invoice
  • Genuine purchase
  • Correct invoice amount
  • Proper approval
  • Payment recorded against the supplier

But the money has gone to a different bank account.

In some cases, that account may belong to an employee, an employee’s relative, or another person connected with the fraud.

This is why verifying the supplier is not enough. The payment destination also needs to be verified.

Why can this be difficult to detect?

Most accounting controls focus on whether the transaction itself is genuine.

For example:

Purchase Order → Goods Received → Invoice → Approval → Payment

If all these documents match, the transaction may appear completely legitimate.

But there is another question that is often overlooked:

Who actually owns the bank account to which the payment was made?

If the supplier’s bank details were changed without independent verification, a genuine transaction can become a fraudulent payment.

A simple control that can reveal a serious problem

One practical review is to compare supplier bank-account information with employee-related bank-account information.

For example, take:

  1. The list of active supplier bank accounts.
  2. The list of employee salary bank accounts.
  3. Compare the bank account numbers.
  4. Where appropriate, also compare IFSC codes and account-holder names.
  5. Investigate any unusual matches.

Suppose a supplier’s bank account happens to be the same as an employee’s salary account.

That does not automatically prove fraud.

There could be a legitimate explanation. For example, the employee may have a genuine business relationship with the supplier or may have been authorised to receive payments in a particular arrangement.

However, such a match is certainly a red flag that deserves investigation.

The same principle can be extended to other unusual relationships, such as supplier bank details matching accounts associated with employees or their related parties.

The bigger control: independently verify changes in bank details

The most important control is not simply comparing account numbers.

It is having a proper process whenever supplier bank details are changed.

For example:

Supplier requests change in bank details
↓
Change request is documented
↓
Supporting bank details are obtained
↓
Independent verification is performed using previously known contact details
↓
Change is approved by an authorised person
↓
Bank details are updated in the accounting system
↓
Payment is released

The key word here is independent.

If the same person who receives the bank-change request can also update the master data and release the payment, the control is considerably weaker.

What businesses should consider implementing

A few simple controls can significantly reduce this risk:

1. Maker-checker control

The person who changes supplier bank details should not be the same person who approves the change.

2. Independent verification

Do not rely solely on the email or message requesting the change.

Verify the change through an independent communication channel, such as a previously registered supplier contact number.

3. Maintain an audit trail

Every change to supplier master data should leave a record showing:

  • Who requested the change
  • Who made the change
  • Who approved it
  • When it was changed
  • What the previous bank details were
  • What the new bank details are
4. Review unusual matches

Periodically compare supplier bank details with employee and other relevant master data to identify unusual overlaps.

5. Review recently changed bank accounts

Payments made shortly after a supplier’s bank details have been changed can receive additional scrutiny, particularly where the transaction is large or unusual.

What about the auditor?

This distinction is important.

The existence of a genuine supplier and genuine invoice does not, by itself, establish that the payment was made to the correct beneficiary.

At the same time, an auditor cannot be expected to detect every fraud simply because a fraud has occurred.

The nature and extent of audit procedures depend on the applicable auditing standards, the circumstances, the assessed risks and the controls in place.

For businesses, the practical lesson is therefore not to rely on the audit alone.

Fraud prevention starts with the company’s internal controls.

The question every finance team should ask

When a supplier’s bank details are changed, ask:

Does someone independent verify that the new bank account actually belongs to the genuine supplier before the payment is released?

If the answer is no, there may be a control gap worth addressing.

Because sometimes the supplier is genuine.

The invoice is genuine.

The purchase is genuine.

The approval is genuine.

And yet the money still goes to the wrong person.

That is why supplier verification and payment verification should be treated as two separate controls.

Final takeaway

A genuine supplier does not automatically mean a genuine payment.

The risk can sit between the invoice and the bank transfer, particularly when supplier master data can be changed without adequate verification.

A simple, well-designed process for supplier bank-account changes, independent verification, maker-checker approval and periodic data analysis can help businesses identify and prevent potentially costly payment fraud.

The real question is not only, “Is this supplier genuine?”

It is also:

“Are we certain that the money is going to the genuine supplier?”

Disclaimer:

This article is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered professional advice. Please consult a qualified expert for advice tailored to your specific situation. The author and website owner are not liable for any errors or actions based on this content.

Board Composition and Independent Directors under Sections 149 and 150 of the Companies Act, 2013: Number, Independence Criteria, Term and Liability

Last updated: 09 October 2026 · Written and reviewed by CA Meet Dhrangadhariya, CSM & Co LLP

Quick summary

  • A public company needs at least three directors, a private company two and a One Person Company one, with a maximum of fifteen (more with a special resolution). Every company needs at least one director who stays in India for 182 days or more in the financial year.
  • A listed public company must have at least one-third of its directors as independent directors, with any fraction rounded up to one.
  • An independent director is not an MD, whole-time director or nominee director, is not a promoter or related to one, has no material pecuniary or employment ties, and must give a declaration of independence at the first Board meeting and every year.
  • The term is up to five consecutive years, with one re-appointment by special resolution, and then a three year cooling off. Liability is limited to acts with his knowledge, consent or connivance, or where he did not act diligently.

Section 149 sets the shape of a company’s Board: how many directors, how many must be independent, and what “independent” means. Section 150 deals with how independent directors are selected.

Number of directors (section 149(1) to (3))

Company Minimum Maximum
Public company 3 15
Private company 2 15
One Person Company 1 15
  • A company may appoint more than fifteen directors after passing a special resolution.
  • The Board must consist of individuals.
  • Classes of companies prescribed by the Rules must have at least one woman director.
  • Resident director: every company must have at least one director who stays in India for a total of not less than 182 days during the financial year. For a newly incorporated company, the requirement applies proportionately at the end of the financial year of incorporation.

Independent directors (section 149(4))

Every listed public company must have at least one-third of the total number of directors as independent directors, and a fraction is rounded up to one. For example, a Board of seven needs three independent directors. The Central Government may prescribe a minimum number of independent directors for other classes of public companies.

Who is an independent director (section 149(6))

An independent director means a director other than a managing director, whole-time director or nominee director, who meets all of these tests:

  1. Integrity and expertise: in the Board’s opinion, a person of integrity with relevant expertise and experience.
  2. Promoters and relations: is not and was not a promoter of the company or its holding, subsidiary or associate company, and is not related to promoters or directors of the company or of its holding, subsidiary or associate company.
  3. Money: has no pecuniary relationship with the company, its holding, subsidiary or associate company, or their promoters or directors, other than remuneration as director or a transaction not exceeding 10% of his total income (or the prescribed amount), during the two immediately preceding financial years or the current financial year.
  4. Relatives: none of his relatives (a) holds securities or an interest in the company group above a face value of Rs 50 lakh or 2% of paid-up capital (or a higher prescribed sum) during that period; (b) is indebted to the company group or its promoters or directors above the prescribed amount; (c) has given a guarantee or security for a third person’s debts to the company group above the prescribed amount; or (d) has any other pecuniary transaction or relationship with the company group amounting to 2% or more of its gross turnover or total income.
  5. Employment and professional ties: neither he nor any relative holds or has held the position of KMP or been an employee of the company group in any of the three financial years before the appointment (a relative’s employment during the preceding three years is not a bar); has been an employee, proprietor or partner in the preceding three years of the company’s firm of auditors, company secretaries in practice or cost auditors, or of any legal or consulting firm that had transactions with the group of 10% or more of that firm’s gross turnover; holds together with his relatives 2% or more of the total voting power; or is a chief executive or director of a non-profit organisation that receives 25% or more of its receipts from the company, its promoters, directors or group companies, or that holds 2% or more of the voting power.
  6. Any other prescribed qualification.

A nominee director is a director nominated by a financial institution under any law or agreement, or appointed by any Government or any other person to represent its interests.

Declaration of independence (section 149(7))

Every independent director gives a declaration that he meets the criteria at the first Board meeting in which he participates, then at the first Board meeting of every financial year, and whenever there is a change in circumstances that may affect his status.

Term (section 149(10), (11) and (13))

  • Up to five consecutive years on the Board of a company.
  • Re-appointment for a further term needs a special resolution and disclosure in the Board’s report.
  • No independent director can hold office for more than two consecutive terms, and he is eligible for appointment again only after three years from ceasing to be an independent director. During those three years he cannot be appointed or associated with the company in any other capacity, directly or indirectly.
  • Any tenure on the date the Act commenced is not counted as a term.
  • The rotation rules for retirement by rotation in section 152(6) and (7) do not apply to independent directors.

Remuneration (section 149(9))

An independent director is not entitled to any stock option. He may receive the sitting fee under section 197(5), reimbursement of expenses for attending Board and other meetings, and profit related commission approved by the members. If the company has no profits or inadequate profits, he may receive remuneration, other than the sitting fee, in accordance with Schedule V.

Limited liability (section 149(12))

An independent director, and a non-executive director who is not a promoter or KMP, is liable only for acts of omission or commission by the company that occurred with his knowledge (attributable through Board processes) and with his consent or connivance, or where he had not acted diligently.

Conduct

The company and independent directors must follow the code in Schedule IV (section 149(8)).

Selection (section 150)

  • An independent director may be selected from a data bank of eligible and willing persons maintained by a body notified by the Central Government. The responsibility of due diligence before selecting a person from the data bank lies with the company.
  • The appointment is approved by the company in general meeting, as provided in section 152(2), and the explanatory statement to the notice must give the justification for choosing the appointee.

A short checklist for the company

  1. Count the directors against the minimum and maximum for your class of company; check the 182 day resident director and the woman director requirement for your class.
  2. If listed, calculate one-third (rounded up) of the Board and plan the independent director appointments in time.
  3. Collect the section 149(7) declaration at the first meeting of each financial year.
  4. Track each independent director’s tenure and the three year cooling-off after two terms.
  5. Record in the explanatory statement why the appointee was chosen, and the data bank search.

Points to check

  • This post follows the Companies Act as published on India Code, including its amendments up to the footnotes in that edition. The classes of companies required to have a woman director or independent directors, the prescribed amounts in the independence tests, the data bank rules and Schedules IV and V are in the Rules and Schedules, which were not reviewed in detail.
  • Listed companies must also comply with SEBI’s listing regulations, which carry further requirements on independent directors and committees.

Frequently asked questions

What is the minimum number of directors?

Three for a public company, two for a private company and one for a One Person Company. The maximum is fifteen, and a company can appoint more than fifteen after passing a special resolution.

Is a resident director required?

Yes. Every company must have at least one director who stays in India for a total of not less than 182 days during the financial year. For a newly incorporated company this applies proportionately at the end of the financial year of incorporation.

How many independent directors must a listed company have?

At least one-third of the total number of directors, with any fraction rounded off to one, in a listed public company. The Central Government may prescribe a minimum number of independent directors for other classes of public companies.

Who is an independent director?

A director other than a managing director, whole-time director or nominee director, who in the Board’s opinion has integrity and relevant expertise and experience, and who meets the tests in section 149(6): not a promoter or related to promoters or directors, no material pecuniary relationship, no relevant relatives’ holdings or transactions, and no past employment or professional connection with the company group within three years.

What is the term of an independent director?

Up to five consecutive years, with re-appointment for a second term on a special resolution and disclosure in the Board’s report. No independent director can hold office for more than two consecutive terms, and is eligible again only after three years, during which he cannot be associated with the company in any other capacity.

Is an independent director entitled to stock options?

No. He can receive sitting fees, reimbursement of expenses and, if the members approve, profit related commission; where the company has no profits or inadequate profits, remuneration in accordance with Schedule V.

When is an independent director liable?

Only in respect of acts of omission or commission by the company which occurred with his knowledge, attributable through Board processes, and with his consent or connivance, or where he had not acted diligently. The same protection applies to a non-executive director who is not a promoter or KMP.

Official sources

Related reading

Disclaimer

This article is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered professional advice. Please consult a qualified expert for advice tailored to your specific situation. The author and website owner are not liable for any errors or actions based on this content.

WhatsApp