Is ESOP Discount a Deductible Expense for the Employer? (Tax Year 2026-27)

Last updated: 17 September 2026 · Written and reviewed by CA Meet Dhrangadhariya, CSM & Co LLP

Quick summary

  • The discount an employer gives on shares issued under an ESOP (market price less exercise price) has been held to be an allowable business expense, as employee compensation.
  • The leading rulings are the ITAT Special Bench and the Karnataka High Court in Biocon, followed by the Delhi High Court.
  • The Income-tax Act, 2025 has no separate provision for it, so the claim rests on the general deduction in section 34 (earlier section 37(1)).
  • The claim is spread over the vesting period, and the employee is separately taxed on the perquisite at exercise.

When a company issues shares to employees under an ESOP at less than the market price, it gives up value. Can the company claim that difference, the “discount”, as an expense in computing its business profits? For years the department said no. The courts have said yes.

The position in the Income-tax Act, 2025

The Act taxes the employee on the benefit: the fair market value on the exercise date less the exercise price is a perquisite (section 17(1)(d) and (4)(h)). It does not carry a matching rule for the employer’s deduction.

The employer’s claim therefore rests on the general deduction in section 34: expenditure, not capital or personal, laid out or expended wholly and exclusively for the purposes of the business or profession, which is not covered by the specific deduction sections. Section 34 corresponds to section 37(1) of the 1961 Act, on which the case law is based. We found nothing in the 2025 Act that changes the reasoning.

Why the department objected

The usual grounds were that no cash leaves the company on a share issue, that the discount is a notional loss of capital receipt rather than an expense, and that the liability is contingent until the employee exercises the option.

What the courts have held

  • Biocon Ltd v DCIT (ITAT Special Bench, Bangalore, 16/07/2013): the discount on ESOP shares is employee remuneration expenditure and allowable under section 37(1).
  • Karnataka High Court in Biocon (reported December 2020): the department’s appeal was dismissed. Where options vest over a period, for example 25% each year over four years, the employee gets a definite right to that portion at each vesting date and the company is bound to allow it. The discount is therefore an ascertained liability, not a contingent one. Section 37(1) does not require a cash pay out.
  • Delhi High Court: the department’s appeals were dismissed in line with Biocon, in the Lemon Tree Hotels matter, and the court has since followed Biocon in the matter reported as PVR Ltd v CIT.

The employer’s deduction is a business expenditure and the employee’s perquisite is a salary item, so one does not depend on the other.

How to claim it

  1. The reported rulings measure the discount as the market price on the grant date less the exercise price, and treat it as accruing as each tranche vests. Claim each tranche in the year it vests, use one method consistently, and take advice on the method before you adopt it.
  2. Keep the plan document, the board and shareholder approvals, the vesting schedule and the valuation with the return.
  3. Deduct and deposit TDS on the employee’s perquisite at exercise, and report it in Form 123 and the salary TDS certificate.
  4. Where the company is an eligible start-up under section 140, the employee’s tax is payable later (within 14 days of the earliest of 60 months, sale or leaving the job), but the employer’s deduction question remains the same.

Before you rely on this

  • The rulings turn on the facts and terms of the plans before the courts. A plan run through a trust, or one where the employer reimburses a trust, can raise separate questions, so look at your own plan terms.
  • The case summaries above are taken from the reports linked below. Read the full order before you quote it to a client.

Frequently asked questions

Is the ESOP discount deductible for the company?

Courts have held that it is employee compensation cost and an allowable business expenditure. The leading ruling is Biocon Ltd, where the ITAT Special Bench (2013) allowed it and the Karnataka High Court upheld that view.

Which section gives the deduction?

The Income-tax Act, 2025 has no section on ESOP discount specifically. The claim is under the general deduction for business expenditure in section 34, which replaced section 37(1) of the 1961 Act.

In which year is the deduction claimed?

The courts have followed the vesting. Where options vest over several years, each vesting gives the employee a definite right, so the discount for that portion is an ascertained liability of that year.

What is the discount?

The difference between the market price of the share and the price at which the option is exercised. The Karnataka High Court treated it as the cost of securing the employees’ services.

Does the employee also pay tax?

Yes. The employee is taxed on the same difference (FMV on exercise less exercise price) as a perquisite under section 17(1)(d). The employer’s deduction and the employee’s perquisite are separate computations.

Official sources

Disclaimer

This article is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered professional advice. Please consult a qualified expert for advice tailored to your specific situation. The author and website owner are not liable for any errors or actions based on this content.

Difference Between Exemption, Deduction and Rebate in Income Tax

Last updated: 29 July 2026 · Written and reviewed by CA Meet Dhrangadhariya, CSM & Co LLP

Quick summary

  • An exemption keeps a particular income out of tax altogether, a deduction reduces your taxable income, and a rebate reduces the tax you have to pay.
  • Examples: agricultural income is exempt, section 80C is a deduction, and the section 87A rebate cuts your computed tax.
  • For Tax Year 2026-27 the new regime gives a rebate of up to ₹60,000 if taxable income is up to ₹12 lakh; the old regime gives up to ₹12,500 if income is up to ₹5 lakh.
  • Most exemptions and deductions (HRA, 80C, 80D) work only in the old regime.

Exemption, deduction, rebate and relief are often used as if they mean the same thing. They do not. Each works at a different stage of the tax calculation, and knowing which is which helps you plan your tax and read your Form 16 correctly.

Exemption

An exemption makes a particular income tax-free. That income is left out of your total income, so it never enters the calculation.

Examples:

  • Agricultural income.
  • House rent allowance (HRA), within the prescribed limit, in the old regime.
  • Leave travel allowance (LTA), on the conditions of the rules, in the old regime.
  • Scholarships granted to meet the cost of education.
  • Gratuity and leave encashment on retirement, up to the limits allowed.

In the Income-tax Act, 2025, which applies from 01/04/2026, most of these exemptions are listed in the Schedules to the Act, while the old section 10 no longer exists as a single section.

Deduction

A deduction is an amount you subtract from your income, because you invested in or spent on something the law encourages. It reduces your taxable income, so the tax saved depends on your slab rate.

Examples:

  • Standard deduction on salary and pension.
  • Section 80C: up to ₹1.5 lakh for PPF, ELSS, life insurance and more.
  • Section 80D: health insurance premium. In the old regime, up to ₹25,000 for self, spouse and children (₹50,000 if a senior citizen), and the same again for parents.
  • Section 80E: interest on an education loan.
  • Section 24(b): home loan interest, up to ₹2 lakh for a self-occupied house.

Rebate

A rebate reduces the tax itself, after it has been computed on your taxable income. The main one is section 87A, available to resident individuals.

New regime (default) Old regime
Taxable income limit ₹12,00,000 ₹5,00,000
Maximum rebate ₹60,000 ₹12,500

These limits apply to Tax Year 2026-27 and to FY 2025-26. Marginal relief is available in the new regime for income slightly above ₹12 lakh. The rebate does not apply to special rate income, such as tax on short term capital gains under section 111A, so read the conditions before relying on it. See our article on the section 87A rebate for a full explanation.

Exemption vs deduction vs rebate: comparison table

Feature Exemption Deduction Rebate
Meaning A specific income is tax-free An amount subtracted from income An amount subtracted from tax
Stage Before total income is arrived at Before taxable income is arrived at After tax is computed
Effect Income is not taxed at all Reduces taxable income Reduces tax payable
Examples Agricultural income, HRA Section 80C, 80D, 80E Section 87A
Most are available in Mostly the old regime Mostly the old regime Both regimes

A note on tax deducted at source (TDS) and tax relief

Rebate, deduction and exemption are not the same as TDS. TDS is tax collected in advance by the payer, such as an employer or bank, on salary, interest, commission, rent or professional fees. It is later adjusted against your final tax, and any excess is refunded to you.

“Tax relief” is a general term for any provision that lowers your tax, including the three above and relief for double taxation. “Tax benefit” is used in the same loose way.

Which is better?

All three help, but they act differently. An exemption removes income completely. A deduction saves tax at your slab rate. A rebate saves a fixed amount of tax. Because most deductions and exemptions work only in the old regime, compare your tax under both regimes every year.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a deduction and an exemption?

An exemption excludes a specific income from tax, for example agricultural income. A deduction is subtracted from your income, for example the section 80C deduction, to reach taxable income.

What is a tax rebate?

A rebate reduces the tax computed on your taxable income. Section 87A is the common example.

Is a rebate the same as a refund?

No. A rebate cuts your tax liability before you pay. A refund is money returned to you when your tax paid or deducted is more than your tax liability.

Which comes first in the calculation?

Exemptions are left out of income first, then deductions are subtracted, tax is calculated on the taxable income, and the rebate is applied to that tax.

Official sources

Related reading

Disclaimer

This article is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered professional advice. Please consult a qualified expert for advice tailored to your specific situation. The author and website owner are not liable for any errors or actions based on this content.

WhatsApp